“Open Content” My thoughts, well the thoughts that I have decided to make mine although really they are an accumulation of many others and therefore I am not sure I can truly call them mine. By, Tara Rynders
The most beneficial advantage of an “open source” culture is the freedom that is given to ones ability to create freely with out inhibition or fear. The idea of experiencing art in this way is a very exciting idea for me. When I experience a piece of work that I really enjoy, a part of me is a little sad that I am not able to participate with that artist in that way because it is “their” art and they can only use that idea. For example I just recently watched a video blog of a dancer in my department titled backyard dances and when watching I immediately wanted to make a video in response to his backyard with my own backyard. Apart of me felt like that would be wrong or infringing upon his idea. He also started a video dance blog, which was in my mind a great idea that I too wanted to explore. After reading The Poetics of the Open Work By, Umbero Eco I was freed from this restriction through these thoughts:
At this point one could object (with reference to the
wider meaning of "openness" already introduced in this essay) that any work of art, even
if it is not passed on to the addressee in an unfinished state, demands a free, inventive
response, if only because it cannot really be appreciated unless the performer somehow
reinvents it in psychological collaboration with the author himself.
This clearly states that his work of art is not fully appreciated by myself until I can reinvent it or a version of it. This is exciting to me because I am often influenced and inspired by others work and now I am understanding that when I experience that type of response it is important to allow that creativity to happen which is a way of appreciating the work of art that inspired me.
Another advantage of the open source is that we rid ourselves of what I call the “precious syndrome”. This idea comes up a lot in beginning dance composition because editing movement can be difficult especially if you think all your movements are precious and cannot be cut out. What if I went into making a dance knowing that all my movements were going to be copied and changed and edited the next day by ten different students? In some ways it takes off so much pressure to create something extremely precious and original that can never be repeated by another. In removing that pressure from one they are able to create what they desire to create minus fear.
Ultimately I must say that I am a huge believer in collaboration because alone I can only go so far with a project and “open source” for me opens up the possibility of huge collaborations with other artists as seen in the you tube clip in B flat.
In response to the idea of copyright and intellectual property in a digital/networking culture I immediately thought no I have no desire to fight for that protection. However on further examination I realized that I had already fought for that protection. When I found out my videos on vimeo were being downloaded in China and multiple other countries I felt disturbed and changed my settings so no one could download MY material. Now giving more thought to this I realize this response comes from many places. One being frustrated that my body and my movement is being used for something and I do not know what that is. I also admit it is the idea that someone is taking something that I made and possibly using it as something they made. This, I believe, is a typical response that we begin to form as a young child. MINE, that is MINE. I think that the idea of wanting ownership over your own work is a legitimate response however it is important for me to address the falsity of the statement that it is all MINE. First off the music for my videos are either the original versions of other artists music or remixed for the video. Some you can recognize others you cannot. Also I must address that all my ideas are simply manifestations of life, which involve all things outside of me as well as me. So to claim that they are MINE demines all the other artists that influenced and offered advice in the creation process of my videos.
The artist’s labor…I believe this is about who has the money and the power. Who is doing the appropriating and gaining monetary benefits from it and is one culture being suppressed from this appropriation. I worry that the ones in power and the ones with money will be able to take over the artist’s labor as seen in the Mickey Mouse phenomenon and those who created prior receive no monetary benefit. The idea of Mickey Mouse can be traced back to black face in African American culture however all the videos and papers written on this on a Google search have been removed from the Internet. Interesting.
http://wiki.asomatic.net/index.php/Mickey_Mouse_as_a_Blackface_Minstrel
The video in this post of Mammy by Al Jolson has been removed.
http://forums.yellowworld.org/showthread.php?t=10853
This site speaks to the origin of Mickey Mouse however the photo image has been removed.
So this is an extreme case of where one idea was taken and now making billions of dollars and no one else is able to touch the mouse. Not even for research purposes. Mickey Mouse has become untouchable even to the Internet. For myself the frustration in this is that our history shows we are a nation of appropriating from African American culture in every way, shape, and form. Why didn’t this conversation begin much earlier? It is a question of power and money not the artists labor. The less privileged have lived in a state of their life being appropriated for a long time and until they are able to fully reciprocate that behavior it becomes an ethical issue for me.
The Rite of Spring is a ballet choreographed by Nijinsky in 1913 in collaboration with composer Stravinsky created for the Ballet Russe under the direction of Serge Diaghilev. It can be viewed on You Tube as performed and directly replicated as close as possible by the Joffrey Ballet:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bjX3oAwv_Fs
In response to this piece of work Pina Bausch created her own version of The Rite of Spring that can be viewed on YouTube:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-NzK0Gg17g
Through Pina Bausch’s interpretation of The Rite of Spring I am able to more fully appreciate the original work. It is an interesting topic in dance because all of dance in order to be re-experienced on stage must be restaged and although it is performed, as close to the original as possible it is still new dancers dancing the parts and adding new small variations that their bodies bring to the movement. However certain people have certain rights to works such as Martha Graham's pieces and now that Pina Bausch has passed away some one will be fighting for the rights of her movement as well. How does one copyright something that happens only in the moment?
I remixed the sound score for a video I made. The music was from Sigur Ros and was mixed with text and other recorded sounds. The original song is called All Alright by Sigur Ros
The Breath We Left
http://www.vimeo.com/6076782